Insurance Defence Lawyer | Civil Litigation Associate | Toronto, ON
- Cartel inc.
- Toronto, Ontario, Canada
- Jun 19, 2026
Job Description
Insurance Defence Lawyer | Civil Litigation Associate | Toronto, ON
A highly regarded litigation-focused law firm in downtown Toronto is actively seeking a Civil Litigation Associate with insurance defence experience to join its expanding legal team. This opportunity is ideal for a lawyer looking to advance their career in a sophisticated litigation environment while handling challenging and diverse insurance-related disputes.
About the Position
The successful candidate will work closely with senior counsel and clients on a wide variety of litigation matters involving insurers, businesses, risk management professionals, and institutional organizations throughout Ontario.
This role offers direct exposure to complex legal disputes, strategic file management, client advisory work, examinations, mediations, motions, and courtroom advocacy.
Practice areas may include:
• Insurance Defence Litigation
• Personal Injury Claims
• Accident Benefits Disputes
• Property Loss and Property Damage Claims
• Occupiers' Liability Matters
• Product Liability Litigation
• Professional Negligence Claims
• Coverage and Indemnity Disputes
• Subrogated Recovery Actions
• Commercial Liability Matters
Key Responsibilities
• Manage litigation files from commencement through resolution
• Draft pleadings, motion materials, mediation briefs, and legal opinions
• Conduct legal research and prepare written advocacy materials
• Attend examinations for discovery, mediations, pre-trials, and court appearances
• Communicate directly with clients, adjusters, experts, and opposing counsel
• Develop litigation strategies and provide practical risk-management advice
• Participate in settlement negotiations and dispute resolution processes
Candidate Requirements
• Licensed to practice law in Ontario
• Minimum 2 years of post-call experience in insurance defence, civil litigation, personal injury, or related litigation practices
• Strong knowledge of Ontario litigation procedure and court processes
• Experience managing multiple active files independently
• Excellent legal writing, advocacy, and analytical abilities
• Superior organizational and time-management skills
• Client-focused approach with strong interpersonal communication skills
• Ability to thrive in a fast-paced, collaborative legal environment
What This Firm Offers
• Established and respected litigation platform
• High-quality insurance and liability litigation work
• Meaningful courtroom and advocacy experience
• Mentorship from accomplished litigators
• Competitive compensation package
• Performance-based bonus opportunities
• Comprehensive health and wellness benefits
• Hybrid work flexibility
• Long-term partnership and career development potential
Why Apply?
This position presents an exceptional opportunity for an ambitious litigation lawyer seeking sophisticated insurance defence work, increased advocacy experience, and a clear path for professional growth within a well-respected Ontario law firm.
Confidential Applications
Ben Higham
Managing Partner | Cartel Inc.
First Canadian Place, Suite 2550
Toronto, Ontario
Keywords: Insurance Defence Lawyer Toronto, Civil Litigation Associate Toronto, Personal Injury Lawyer Jobs Ontario, Insurance Litigation Jobs Toronto, Litigation Counsel Ontario, Accident Benefits Lawyer, Occupiers Liability Lawyer, Subrogation Litigation, Professional Liability Associate, Commercial Litigation Lawyer Toronto.
What is it about Cartel that makes us different?
We have been successfully placing candidates with the leading law firms in the Greater Toronto Area since 1975, which means that we have 34 years of experience in the legal industry. This in turn has allowed Cartel to build and develop close and meaningful relationships with Toronto's most prestigious legal organizations, many of which have become trusted friends and partners over time.
Our consultants have been with us for 10 to 20 years and are among the most experienced and dedicated in the legal field today. Their expertise and commitment are a key element in establishing our reputation as Toronto's most trusted legal authority.
At Cartel, our relationship with our candidates is based on a foundation of trust and mutual respect. We'll take the time to really talk about what's important to you and not just what's available. Our consultants will personally assess your strengths and abilities to quickly identify which positions you would be ideally suited for. We will prepare you thoroughly for your interviews and provide you with honest and detailed information regarding our clients. All the information you give us about yourself remains strictly confidential. Our commitment to you is one hundred percent.
These are but a few of the reasons, which distinguish us from the competition. We're good listeners, just ask your friends - they'll tell you.
Cartel. We're good at what we do.
Toronto's Most Trusted Authority in Legal Personnel.