Gore Mutual Insurance

In-House Counsel – Insurance Defense (Casualty & Accident Benefits) Location: Ontario (Hybrid/Remote options may apply) Company: Gore Mutual (A Beneva Member) The Opportunity: Scale Your Impact in a Transforming Industry At Gore Mutual , we’ve always been a modern mutual that does good. Now, we’re doing even more. As of January 1, 2026, Gore has joined Beneva —Canada’s largest mutual insurance company. Throughout 2026, we are integrating with Unica Insurance to build a powerhouse in the Property & Casualty sector. We are seeking a high-caliber In-House Counsel to join us during this era of growth. This isn't just a litigation role; it’s an opportunity to be part of a strengthened, diversified legal team that remains anchored in the long-term benefits of our members and communities. The Role: End-to-End Litigation Excellence As In-House Counsel, you will lead the charge in driving Casualty and Accident Benefit files to timely, strategic resolutions. You will act as a key legal partner to claims adjusters and leadership, providing the technical insight necessary to navigate Ontario’s evolving legal landscape. Your mandate includes: Case Management: Independently manage a diverse portfolio of 50+ files, tailored to your level of expertise. Full-Cycle Litigation: Lead files from initial assignment through discovery, mediation, and pre-trials, to final resolution via settlement or trial/arbitration. Strategic Advocacy: Represent the company in contested motions, arbitrations, trials, and appeals. Process Innovation: Identify opportunities for technical excellence and deliver targeted legal training to the broader organization. Collaborative Leadership: Foster high-performing relationships with legal support staff and internal clients to drive efficient outcomes. What You Bring to the Table Professional Credentials: A J.D. or LL.B. and a member in good standing with the Law Society of Ontario . Proven Experience: 3–8 years of litigation experience, specifically within insurance defense (Casualty/AB). Courtroom Readiness: Demonstrated success in contested motions, mediations, and trials/arbitrations. Analytical Rigor: Exceptional legal research skills and a "digital-first" approach to legal resources. Communication Mastery: The ability to translate complex legal risks into clear, actionable advice for non-legal stakeholders. Total Rewards & Culture We believe in rewarding the expertise that drives our stability. Base Salary: $97,500 – $147,500 (Commensurate with experience and qualifications). Incentives: Participation in Gore Mutual’s discretionary bonus program. Benefits: Comprehensive health/dental, disability insurance, and retirement plan matching. Environment: A collaborative, inclusive team culture that values long-term professional growth and community impact. SEO Keywords for Job Boards Primary Keywords: In-House Counsel, Insurance Defense Lawyer, Litigation Counsel Ontario, Casualty Claims Solicitor, Accident Benefits Lawyer. Secondary Keywords: Beneva careers, Gore Mutual legal jobs, P&C Insurance law, Insurance litigation 50+ files, Ontario Bar legal roles. How to Apply Join a legacy that’s transforming for the better. Gore Mutual is an equal opportunity employer. We are committed to providing accommodations for people with disabilities throughout the recruitment process. If you require an accommodation, we will work with you to meet your needs.